Port Glasgow figures hit back at Carbuncle Award decision

Inverclyde MSP Stuart McMillan says Port Glasgow is 'full of potential and progress' <i>(Image: Jim Canning)</i>
Inverclyde MSP Stuart McMillan says Port Glasgow is 'full of potential and progress' (Image: Jim Canning)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

PORT Glasgow and Inverclyde representatives have have hit back after the town was given a controversial prize for the ‘most dismal town in Scotland’.

The Carbuncle Awards, run by the Urban Realm journal, named the town as the winner of the ‘Plook on the Plinth’ title on Wednesday.

The news provoked uproar from residents, politicians and other local figures, who quickly jumped to its defence.

Among the first to speak up in support of the town was the Rev William Boyle, minister at Port Glasgow New Parish Church.

In a social media post, he said: "I love Port Glasgow. I love being parish minister in Port Glasgow.

William Boyle, minister at Port Glasgow New Parish Church, spoke up in defence of the town.William Boyle, minister at Port Glasgow New Parish Church, spoke up in defence of the town. (Image: alex craig) "I love our historic building, open seven days a week from morning until night serving this amazing town.

"I love being the chaplain to local schools and the shipyard in Port Glasgow. I love the views across the Clyde and walking along the front.

"I love that we have Coronation Park for various church events like Picnic in the Park. I love relaxing and catching up with folk at the retail park.

"I love the people, the best folk you could ever meet...the list goes on.

Inverclyde MSP Stuart McMillan took to social media to share his own experience of Port Glasgow, as well as praising work currently being done to regenerate the area.


READ MORE: Provost blasts decision to name Port Glasgow 'the most dismal town in Scotland'


Mr McMillan said: “For some, kicking Port Glasgow might seem like a bit of fun – but these so-called ‘awards’ don’t just target a place, they denigrate the people who live there. That’s not acceptable.

“I grew up in Port Glasgow, and know first-hand what a great place it is to live.

“Yes, like many town centres across the UK, Port Glasgow faces challenges – but it’s also a town full of potential and progress.”

The MSP cited the demolition and plans for development of Clune Park, accessibility improvements at Port Glasgow train station and employment opportunities at Kelburn Industrial Estate as examples of the town ‘changing’.

Stuart McMillan insisted there were plenty of reasons to talk up Port Glasgow.Stuart McMillan insisted there were plenty of reasons to talk up Port Glasgow. (Image: alex craig) He added: “Rather than handing out negative labels, we should be focusing on how to support towns like Port Glasgow.

“This should serve as a wake-up call to all stakeholders – public and private – that doing nothing is not an option.

“But let’s also recognise the progress already being made and the pride that local people rightly feel in their community.

“Any objective person visiting Port Glasgow would see a town with challenges, yes—but also with resilience, ambition, and a much brighter future ahead.”

The award was brought to Inverclyde by Urban Realm editor John Glenday on Wednesday.

Port Glasgow hasn't been short of defenders since the editor of Urban Realm magazine announced the town as the latest Plook on the Plinth winner.Port Glasgow hasn't been short of defenders since the editor of Urban Realm magazine announced the town as the latest Plook on the Plinth winner. (Image: Jim Canning/Greenock Telegraph Camera Club)

He intended to present it to Kevin Green of the Port Glasgow 2025 initiative.

But Mr Green, who accused Mr Glenday of 'a poverty safari', refused to accept the prize, leaving Mr Glenday to resort to placing it on top of a bin in Shore Street.

The local businessman told the BBC: “Nobody’s accepted the award and I think he’ll struggle to find somebody in Port Glasgow who will accept the award.

“I think the best place for the award is where it ended up – which is sitting on top of a bin.

“I’d have preferred if he put it in the bin, so no other town gets it.”

A post shared on Port Glasgow 2025’s social media on Wednesday evening stated: “Port Glasgow has a plan. We are looking for a leg up, not a hand out.

(Image: William Kelly) “Every new story starts from a place of discomfort.

“We can’t promise you world-beating success. We can’t promise you another Comet. We can’t promise you another Goliath.

“We can promise you adventure and a bit of fun.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos