Plans for cruise ship levy in Inverclyde branded 'penny pinching'

A levy on cruise ships would make Inverclyde look 'penny pinching', a councillor has claimed. <i>(Image: George Munro)</i>
A levy on cruise ships would make Inverclyde look 'penny pinching', a councillor has claimed. (Image: George Munro)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

PROPOSALS to introduce a levy on cruise ships visiting Inverclyde will make the area look ‘penny-pinching’, according to a senior councillor.

Conservative councillor David Wilson told a meeting of a key local authority committee of his fear that introducing a fee risks 'killing the goose that lays the golden egg'.

Councillor Wilson made his opposition to the levy known after members of the council's environment and regeneration committee were asked to rubber-stamp, or 'homologate', a response from the authority to a Scottish Government consultation on the issue.

Officers from the council submitted the authority's response to the consultation back in May, but the response did not come before elected councillors for final ratification until after the summer recess.

In their response, council officials said they believed a levy would have a ‘very positive impact’ on local communities, and were supportive of the idea of giving local authorities the power to create a cruise ship levy in their areas.

However, Cllr Wilson said that he, along with his Conservative colleague councillor Graeme Brooks and independent Innes Nelson, were not in favour of the move, and would be minded to oppose it if the opportunity arose.

He said: “The group I’m a part of, the three of us, we’re not in favour of a levy.”

He continued: “We are more than likely to object to it and raise an amendment or a motion.

(Image: Duncan Bryceland)

“In the main I think that Peel Ports have done a lot at the [cruise ship] terminal. They’ve invested in the container terminal with new cranes.

“We have created ourselves, with government money, the terminal area, with Scotts restaurant.

“We’ve put a lot of work in there, and the number of cruise ships is increasing. I think that McGills and a lot of the bus companies are doing a very good job to take the cruise passengers wherever they want to go.

“I think that we’re in danger of killing the goose that laid the golden egg here, and we think it should be well left alone.

“I think it makes us look a bit penny pinching to be charging passengers a pound or two to arrive in Greenock.”

(Image: Inverclyde Council)

But Cllr Wilson’s views were not shared by all of his fellow committee members.

Labour councillor Jim Clocherty told the former depute Provost he ‘wholeheartedly’ disagreed with his position.

He said: “The principle of cruise levies, or tourist tax, or levies on overnight stays, are now probably well enshrined wherever you go.

“Wherever you go in the world now you’re paying some sort of levy to help the locality to do whatever they say they’re going to do, and the cruise ship levy is no different from that.”

He added: “I think the cruise ship levy for us as a council is a no brainer. It will not be used, unless members decide to use it, on something like lowering the council tax.

“It would go, if we as councillors wish it, to help the environment, to help stimulate the local area and to provide that benefit for local people as well.”

Councillor Paul Cassidy said he was in favour of a levy, but added that he hoped that the Scottish Government would not put constraints on how the money raised can be used by local authorities.

(Image: Contributed)

He said: “We’ve seen other places in the world where this has worked. It’s not deterred cruise passengers.

“I’ve spoken to some people in the cruise ship industry, and they’ve said they don’t see it as a deterrent to people coming into Inverclyde.”

Councillor Wilson interjected to ask whether Councillor Cassidy was referring to Peel Ports, which leases Greenock’s cruise ship terminal to operators Global Ports Holding.

Councillor Cassidy replied: “We’re talking about the actual cruise ship companies, not just Peel."

Inverclyde Council’s SNP group leader Chris Curley indicated that his group was also in favour of a levy and said he personally felt it was ‘right and proper’.

(Image: Inverclyde Council)

He added: “It’s also an opportunity to maybe invest in some the facilities that tourists would want to come and see. It’s about building that tourist economy in Inverclyde.

“It would maybe then enable us to attract more homegrown tourists as well, it’s all part of that ecosystem.

“It’s great to see this finally coming in. I wish it had happened before now.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos