Ferguson Marine management criticised over ferries bid

MSPs Stuart McMillan and Jamie Greene told a Holyrood debate of their belief in a positive future for Ferguson Marine, while hitting out at past failures in the oversight of the yard. <i>(Image: George Munro (main image), Scottish Parliament)</i>
MSPs Stuart McMillan and Jamie Greene told a Holyrood debate of their belief in a positive future for Ferguson Marine, while hitting out at past failures in the oversight of the yard. (Image: George Munro (main image), Scottish Parliament)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

BOSSES at Ferguson Marine have been accused of ‘failing spectacularly’ over an unsuccessful bid to win a £175 million contract to build a fleet of new Caledonian MacBrayne ferries.

Local MSP Stuart McMillan said top brass at the state-owned Port Glasgow yard had let down workers, the Inverclyde community and taxpayers over a ‘foolish’ decision to put a successful bid for the contract at the heart of a previous business plan.

And his Greenock-born colleague, Jamie Greene, warned that if the yard is eventually forced to close due to a lack of work, it would be a ‘national shame’ for Scotland.



The two politicians criticised past failures in the oversight of the yard, while opposition MSPs also slammed the Scottish Government’s approach, with one accusing the SNP of claiming the yard’s fortunes, or misfortunes, are ‘nothing to do with them’ – something denied by Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes.

The £175m deal – the first phase of the ‘small vessel replacement programme’ for CalMac’s Clyde and Hebrides network – was awarded by the Scottish Government to the Remontowa yard in Poland earlier this year.

During a Holyrood debate on an audit of the company, carried out by the parliament’s public audit committee, which published its findings in July, Mr McMillan said: “It was foolish in the extreme for the yard management to decide to include the small vessel replacement programme 1 direct award order in the previous business plan.

Stuart McMillan MSP (Image: contributed)

"I know that I am not alone in thinking that.

“The 65 per cent to 35 per cent ratio of quality and cost respectively gave the yard’s board and management a prime opportunity to win the work.

"However, they did not just fail - they failed spectacularly, letting down the workers, the local community and the taxpayer.”

The Ferguson Marine yard in Port Glasgow (Image: Duncan Bryceland)

Opposition MSPs criticised the Scottish Government over its pledge to make £14.2 million available to upgrade Ferguson Marine’s shipbuilding facilities, but to have made, so far, only £500,000 of that available to the yard.

Mr McMillan said: "The key to boosting the yard’s efficiency, and putting it in a position to secure some of that work, is for the board and the management to work effectively and efficiently and to turn our yard – because it is our yard – into a yard that we can all be proud of, and to support our workers.”

Jamie Greene MSP (Image: Scottish Parliament)

Mr Greene, who represents the West Scotland region for the Liberal Democrats, and who sits on the public audit committee, said: “When the committee went to Port Glasgow, we saw a yard that was clearly willing to rise – and capable of rising – to  the challenge to take on new projects and grasp new opportunities, but those opportunities have continued to pass it by.

“The shipyard has a future. Its failure is not inevitable, but neither is its success.

“If the yard fails and if it closes its doors for ever, that will not be an embarrassment for the Government; it will be a national shame.”

Kate Forbes MSP

Ms Forbes said: “We take ownership of and responsibility for what has happened at the yard.

“That £14.2 million is still available. But it has to be invested in line with subsidy control rules and in line with the business case. 

“We recognise the reputational challenges that have been caused by past delays. There are clear signs that Ferguson Marine’s standing has improved.



“The yard’s technical bid for the first phase of the small vessel replacement programme was rated as very strong; cost was the only factor in the final decision.

“That should encourage us all to recognise not only the talent in the yard, but its potential to secure work as it nears the completion of the Glen Rosa.”

MSPs voted to note the committee’s report and to “call on the Scottish Government to fulfil its commitment to invest all of the £14.2m promised to modernise the yard to enable Ferguson Marine (Port Glasgow) to secure orders”.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos