Cost of delayed Ferguson ferry Glen Rosa rises by £12.5m

MV Glen Rosa at Ferguson Marine <i>(Image: George Munro)</i>
MV Glen Rosa at Ferguson Marine (Image: George Munro)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

THE boss of Ferguson Marine shipyard has revealed the cost of building the new MV Glen Rosa ferry has risen by an additional £12.5m.

This means the total cost of the vessel is almost £200m.

The nationalised Port Glasgow shipyard confirmed last year that the ferry - initially due for delivery in 2018 - would not hit the waters until late 2026.

That means, after sea trials, it almost certainly won't be serving the Arran island route until early 2027.

Ferguson Marine bosses confirmed, in a letter to the Scottish Parliament's Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee, that the total cost of the Glen Rosa has risen to £197.5m.

The shipyard's chief executive, Graeme Thomson, wrote: "Although this position is regrettable, we are confident in the updated timeline and cost forecast.

"We look forward to informing the committee on our progress in our next update."

Graeme Thomson, CEO of Ferguson Marine (Image: Ferguson Marine)

Reacting to the news, Greenock-born West Scotland MSP and Scottish Liberal Democrat economy spokesperson Jamie Greene said: "This is almost five times what the boat was originally supposed to cost, you could have built four ferries for the same price.

"If I went in a pub where a pint was a fiver and it ended up costing me £25 I'd walk out, but the SNP are knee deep in manure over this issue because they will have to keep chucking public at this project until it’s finished.

"Ministers were warned that it would have been cheaper to scrap the vessel and start again, they ignored advice and ploughed on. Meanwhile they’re giving ferry contracts to Poland and Turkey snubbing Scottish shipbuilders.

“Not a single minister has ever resigned over this scandal. Coastal communities like Ardrossan have never seen a penny of compensation for the disruption.

"It’s a massive display of arrogance that people in the west of Scotland won’t forget.”

Both Glen Rosa and sister ship MV Glen Sannox were supposed to cost just £97m. Now, the cost of both ships is estimated at almost £500m.

That price includes £83m paid out before the shipyard was nationalised, along with £45m of government loans that have now been mostly written off.

The former owners of the shipyard claimed government agency Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd (CMAL) had botched the initial concept design.

MV Glen Rosa at Ferguson Marine (Image: George Munro)

CMAL insisted the yard's management underestimated how complex the work would be and made poor decisions. The decision to make both ferries dual-fuelled, using LNG (liquified natural gas) is also believed to have caused major issues.

Glen Sannox was finally launched on the Arran route a year ago. It had to sail from Troon Harbour because the design of the vessels ensured they could not berth at the island's mainland port of Ardrossan.

Negotiations between Ardrossan Harbour owners Peel Ports and CMAL over a takeover of the port continue to drag on. Until that happens, a previously agreed multi-million-pound redevelopment of Ardrossan Harbour cannot begin.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos