Inverclyde MSP 'never totally convinced' by assisted dying Bill

MSPs voted on the Bill after a debate at Holyrood last night <i>(Image: Jane Barlow/PA Wire)</i>
MSPs voted on the Bill after a debate at Holyrood last night (Image: Jane Barlow/PA Wire)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

INVERCLYDE’S MSP says he was 'never totally convinced’ by legislation which would have seen Scotland back assisted dying after the plans were voted down at Holyrood.

Stuart McMillan was one of 69 MSPs who voted against the Bill at the Scottish Parliament on Tuesday night.

A total of 57 MSPs backed the Bill, with one member abstaining.

The legislation was introduced by Liam McArthur, MSP for Orkney, who insisted it would be the ‘most safeguarded assisted dying law anywhere in the world’.

Many MSPs, however, raised concerns over its potential impact on vulnerable Scots and the risk of coercion.

During a debate immediately before the vote, Mr McMillan confirmed that he would not be backing the Bill.

Following the vote, he told the Telegraph: “I met with Liam McArthur’s team as early as November 2021 to discuss his proposals for assisted dying.

“Even at that early stage, I raised the idea of a referendum to enable the electorate to have the final say over any legislation if passed. Sadly, my amendment calling for a referendum was not accepted.

“Nonetheless, throughout the whole legislative process, I’ve engaged with individuals and organisations on both sides of the debate, because I’ve never had a strong belief either for or against the principle.

“Seeing family members suffer a terminal illness led to me being supportive of the idea, but I’ve never been totally convinced.



“In many ways, my decision on how to vote would have been much easier if I had a strong opinion either way.

“Ultimately, no matter how I chose to vote, I could not please everyone I represent.

“Although I voted against the Bill at stage one, I worked with Liam to propose amendments at stage two and three.

"I felt a strong duty, in the event the Bill did pass, to ensure I did everything I could to try to put in place strong safeguards for patients and medical professionals.

“So, while I chose not to vote for the final Bill, I did not arrive at this decision lightly.

“I’ve outlined the rationale for my decision on my website, which I would encourage everyone with an interest in this issue to read.”

Jamie Greene MSP voted in favour of the Bill (Image: Contributed)

Greenock-born MSP Jamie Greene, who represents the West Scotland region, voted in favour of the legislation.

He praised fellow MSPs following the vote, saying the debate was carried out ‘respectfully’ and was example of Holyrood ‘at its very best’.

Mr Greene added: “My colleague, Liam McArthur, guided his Bill impeccably and with grace and seriousness.

“Although the Bill was amended heavily, addressing many of the concerns that members raised, it fell by a narrow margin.

“I was personally disappointed to see this, and believe that parliament has failed to grasp a key opportunity to help those who need it achieve a dignified and compassionate death.

“While Scotland continues to slip behind the curve on assisted dying, there is reason to hope that this high-profile debate will spur politicians on to deliver palliative care that was promised and that far too many people are denied.

“This issue is extremely important to me, which is why I was proud to secure nearly £10 million for hospices in my budget deal.

“I also hope that this will be the beginning of an open and stigma-free conversation about death and dying in Scotland.”

null (Image: Newsquest)

Similar legislation is progressing through the UK Parliament at Westminster and is currently at the committee stage in the House of Lords.

Inverclyde and West Renfrewshire MP Martin McCluskey said: “The failure of the Assisted Dying Bill in the Scottish Parliament reflects the very real and deeply held concerns that many people have about this issue.

“I have consistently opposed the Assisted Dying Bill currently progressing through the UK Parliament, and that position has not changed.

“While I understand the arguments put forward by supporters, I remain of the view that the safeguards are not robust enough, and that there are serious risks when it comes to protecting vulnerable people.

“At its heart, this is about ensuring that those who are elderly, disabled or facing difficult circumstances are properly supported and never feel under pressure to make such a profound decision.

“I will continue to oppose the legislation at Westminster and stand up for the strongest possible protections for vulnerable people.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos