JOHN Swinney has insisted Ferguson Marine has a 'secure future' despite the yard being frozen out of bidding for a major CalMac ferry contract because of delays in getting the Glen Rosa into the water.
The Port Glasgow shipyard has confirmed it will not bid to build a replacement for the MV Lord of the Isles as it cannot meet the eligibility criteria set by Caledonian Maritime Assets Limited (CMAL).
The Scottish Government agency’s prequalification process requires bidders to demonstrate they have delivered at least two vessels longer than 75 metres in the past five years.
However, this does not include ships still under construction.
Read more
Swinney snubs Joanna Cherry's book and dismisses claims over Salmond 'spy' allegation
‘Martin Compston sees the danger of Reform’, says Swinney during Greenock visit
🗳️Unspun Election Briefing: Green fever
Ferguson Marine delivered the MV Glen Sannox in November 2024, but its sister vessel, the MV Glen Rosa, is not due for completion until later this year.
The yard’s chief executive, Graeme Thomson, said the criteria effectively ruled out UK shipbuilders altogether.
He added: “While we were eager to bring this project back to the Clyde, a rigorous review of the tender prequalification criteria indicates that, in our view, it is unlikely that any UK shipbuilder would meet the stipulated minimum qualification requirements.
“The original vessel was built here at Ferguson’s and has served the CalMac fleet for 36 years, a testament to the enduring quality of Scottish craftsmanship.
“However, without a procurement model that scores UK social and economic value and builds domestic supply chain resilience, which is in line with government nationwide guidance, UK shipyards remain at a disadvantage against heavily subsidised foreign competitors.”
John Swinney visited Greenock Morton on the campaign trail (Image: Robert Perry)
The GMB, which represents workers at Ferguson Marine, called for the tender process to be halted.
Speaking to the press during a campaign stop in Greenock last week, the First Minister said the Scottish Government had 'explored' whether a direct award could be made to Ferguson Marine for the replacement vessel for the Lord of the Isles, but that 'for a whole variety of technical reasons' this was not possible.
He told Press Association: “The Scottish Government has already allocated two major vessels to the Ferguson Marine shipyard, the Glen Sannox, which is now in service, and the Glen Rosa, which is approaching completion.
“But we have also allocated four more vessels to Fergusons which will provide the yard with a workload through direct award in the small vessels and also in marine patrol vessels.
“So the Scottish Government is making it abundantly clear that Fergusons has got a secure future because it will have a workload delivered by the Scottish Government.”
But he insisted: “What we are able to make sure is that a number of vessel contracts go to Fergusons and that is what the Scottish Government has already set out to Parliament.”
Scottish Liberal Democrat economy spokesman Jamie Greene described it as 'the final farcical fallout from the SNP’s pitiful management of our ferries'.
He added: “Because of their shameful mismanagement, the Glen Rosa is so late to be delivered that it cannot be used as evidence to support a bid for a contract from their own ferry building agency. It is a slap in the face to the workers. The people of Inverclyde deserve better than this shambles.
“Scotland was a proud shipbuilding nation and the SNP have utterly ruined that reputation at enormous cost to both shipyard workers and islanders.
“Ferguson Marine needs contracts if it is to have a future.”
Read more
Greens' Polanski says Scotland 'treated like children' over second independence vote
Angry Aberdeen audience confront SNP minister over lack of support for oil and gas
Private schools told not to expect bailout as questions remain over VAT impact
CMAL defended its approach, saying the criteria had 'been designed to ensure the best outcome for island communities'.
The agency has also argued that incorporating social value scoring into the evaluation could conflict with procurement rules requiring 'equal treatment' and 'non-discrimination' between bidders.
Share