Exclusive

ScotGov four-vessel plan faces Ferguson Marine doubts

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The Scottish Government's pre-election pledge to hand Ferguson Marine direct contracts to build four new ships without competition has been put into question amid legal concerns over direct awards.

The uncertainty follows confirmation from former transport secretary Fiona Hyslop that ministers previously ruled out directly awarding the Port Glasgow yard a major ferry contract because of subsidy control concerns and the risk of legal challenge.

Two ferries under CMAL’s small vessel replacement programme (SVRP), and two marine protection vessels, are in line to be built in Port Glasgow without open competition as part of a major lifeline for the state-owned yard.

When the direct award to the yard was announced in March, ministers said the award was subject to legal and subsidy control checks and that engagement with the Competition and Markets Authority was among the steps still required before any formal contract awards could be made.

(Image: George Munro)

It has since been confirmed by the government that a contract to build a replacement for CalMac’s MV Lord of the Isles ferry will not be directly awarded to Ferguson’s, and will instead go out to competitive tender.

The deal to built the first seven vessels in the SVRP was awarded to the Remontowa yard in Gdansk, Poland, last year following an open tendering process in which Ferguson Marine also bid.

The Scottish Government has already turned down a request from unions and the yard to allow past direct awards of vessel contracts to Ferguson Marine.

An industry insider said: "The possibility of issuing a direct award to Ferguson Marine was fully explored during the procurement of the seven vessel contract that ultimately went to the Polish yard, and again [it would appear] during the process for replacing the Lord of the Isles.



"On both occasions, the Scottish Government concluded Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd could not proceed with a direct award.

"As such, it is difficult to comprehend how on the third asking of the same question, a different legal outcome could magically appear.

"While there remains some hope that the Scottish Government can pull a rabbit out of the hat on this third attempt, Ferguson's ability to pursue additional work may be significantly constrained.

"Ferguson could be forced to decline other opportunities, if taking them on might later compromise its capacity to meet CMAL’s delivery and CalMac’s operational requirements."

MV Glen Rosa being fitted out at Ferguson Marine, Port Glasgow.MV Glen Rosa is currently due for delivery to CMAL towards the end of this year. (Image: George Munro)

A ferry user group official said that there would be concern Ferguson Marine might be "hamstrung" at a time when it needs urgent new business to turn its fortunes around, and when there were "undeniable questions" over whether the Scottish Government could actually follow through with the direct award.

"If the Scottish Government do not make the direct award,” they said, “the future of Ferguson Marine, which is already precarious, would be in real jeopardy.

“People who use our lifeline services would rather see Made in Scotland, in relation to ferries, than Made in Turkey."

A Scottish Government spokesman said: “As has previously been made clear, the direct award is subject to due diligence processes to assess viability but is expected to secure a pipeline of work and allow the shipyard to move ahead with its modernisation plans while pitching for additional orders on the open market.

“Since nationalisation, the Scottish Government has taken steps to secure a sustainable future for the yard and the skilled jobs it provides.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos