Prisoner found not guilty of hiding sharpened metal in cell

 <i>(Image: Newsquest)</i>
(Image: Newsquest)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A PRISONER has been acquitted of having a sharp piece of metal in his cell at HMP Greenock after telling jurors he believed the item was hidden there by another inmate.

Francis Kelly stood trial at Greenock Sheriff Court this week over an allegation dating back to August 2024.

The trial heard officers from the Scottish Prison Service’s National Tactical Search Unit arrived at Mr Kelly’s cell shortly before 7am.

The sharpened metal, which measured around three inches, was discovered underneath his bed, which was bolted to the floor.

Mr Kelly - who was classed as a 'low risk' prisoner at the time - had confirmed to the officers that there was nothing sharp in the cell before the search commenced.

During the trial, he told jurors he held a ‘position of trust’ within the prison and was serving as the hall painter.

The court heard that paint, brushes and rollers were stored within Mr Kelly's cell, which other prisoners would have access to in order to collect the items they needed.

Recalling the moment he was informed of the officers' findings, he said: “I wasn’t happy about it. I told them it had nothing to do with me.

“I had too much to lose to have something like that in my cell.”

Mr Kelly said he was told by others that the item had been placed in his cell by another prisoner.

He believed this was done out of ‘pure badness’ in the hopes that Mr Kelly would be sacked from his painting role.

In her closing remarks to the jury, prosecutor Mandy Robertson invited the jurors to convict Mr Kelly of being in possession of a bladed or sharply-pointed article without reasonable excuse or lawful authority.

She noted that he was the sole occupant of his cell, and that the metal was found in a place ‘under his day-to-day control’.

Defence solicitor David Kinloch told the jury: “Look at how Mr Kelly gave evidence. If you believe Mr Kelly, that’s the end of it.”

Mr Kinloch also highlighted that it was not known whether Mr Kelly’s DNA was present on the piece of metal, as it was not sent for analysis after it was recovered.

Following the brief trial at Greenock Sheriff Court, during which evidence was heard over the course of one day, the jury returned a unanimous not guilty verdict.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos