Plans to axe 15 firefighter posts in Greenock set to be approved

2
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

CONTROVERSIAL proposals to axe firefighter posts in Greenock are set to be approved at a meeting of service chiefs next week.

The Scottish Fire and Rescue Service Board is set to meet on Monday, June 22, to consider the outcomes of its nationwide Service Delivery Review (SDR).

Ahead of the meeting, it is being recommended that the second wholetime appliance at Greenock be permanently changed from a combined aerial rescue pump (CARP) to a dedicated high reach appliance (HRA), resulting in a reduction of 15 firefighter posts in Inverclyde.

Greenock’s second wholetime appliance’s capability to pump water was ‘temporarily’ removed in September 2023 and has only been used as a high reach appliance since.



If proposals are approved, this vehicle will be permanently replaced with a dedicated high-reach vehicle.

The recommended move is one of two options that were presented to the public in the fire service’s SDR consultation last year.

The other option included changing Greenock’s second appliance to a high reach but would also have seen cuts made to wholetime fire cover at Port Glasgow.

(Image: George Munro)

During last year’s consultation, campaigners, union officials and politicians claimed that any change to fire cover locally could put lives at risk.

In internal documents uncovered by the Telegraph last year, fire service bosses admitted that both changes would lead to a ‘moderate’ increase in response times for some local appliances.

Now, in a report published ahead of next week's meeting, the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service's own modelling shows that the impact the proposed change with have on the average response time of the second fire engine that attends an incident is 'significant'.



It states that response times will increase by upwards of three and a half minutes, from a base response time of four minutes and 20 seconds.

The report to the board adds: “Evaluation provides confidence that the temporary configuration is effective and that permanent transition from a CARP to a dedicated HRA is appropriate and deliverable.

“The area has a high density of pumping appliances when compared to other areas with similar risk and demand. This is confirmed by the low levels of incident demand experienced at Greenock and Port Glasgow stations when compared to the other stations with the same number of pumping appliances and the same crewing configurations.

Firefighters were called to tackle a blaze at Greenock bus depotControversial changes to fire cover in Greenock are set to be approved. (Image: Duncan Bryceland)

“Demand analysis identified that Greenock has a low level of mobilisations compared to other Scottish stations with two wholetime pumps. Simulation Modelling has evidenced that withdrawing a wholetime pumping appliance from Greenock would have one of the lowest impacts on Second Attending Pumping Appliance response times.

“This is why the operational role of the Greenock CARP was temporarily reduced to that of a dedicated HRA as part of the temporary wholetime pump withdrawals in 2023.”

Chief Officer Stuart Stevens said: “The Service Delivery Review is about ensuring we have a fire and rescue service that is fit for the future – one that responds to changing risks and continues to protect people, communities and firefighters across Scotland.



“We recognise that these proposals represent significant change, and we have listened carefully to the strength of feeling expressed by local communities, our staff and stakeholders throughout the consultation process. That feedback has helped to inform the recommendations now being considered by the Board.

“Our priority throughout has been, and remains, public and firefighter safety. These proposals are focused on ensuring our resources are in the right places to meet risk and demand, while maintaining an effective, equitable and resilient emergency service for all of Scotland’s communities.

“It is important to emphasise that no final decisions have yet been taken. All recommendations remain subject to full consideration and approval by the SFRS Board.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos