MSPs are being urged to investigate how Ferguson Marine was frozen out of lucrative CalMac ferry contracts after a procurement process was fast-tracked to Turkey.
GMB Scotland, the biggest union at the Port Glasgow yard, has written to Holyrood's transport committee calling for a probe into why work was rushed to Turkish shipbuilder Cemre Marin Endustri.
Union leaders say the tender was effectively 'stitched up' by state-owned ferry procurement body Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd (CMAL), with the process planned and signed off by Transport Scotland and the Scottish Government.
The call for an investigation comes after the Telegraph's sister title, The Herald, revealed secret papers showing Transport Scotland officials believed speeding up the procurement was likely to result in Cemre winning the work.
Three ferries were to be built for CalMac in Turkey (Image: CMAL)
The contracts were for two additional ferries, based on the same design as two vessels already being built by Cemre in Turkey.
Procurement went ahead, and the two contracts were ultimately awarded to Cemre.
Ferguson Marine did not submit a bid.
The yard's biggest union has now called for MSPs to examine how the procurement was handled.
Louise Gilmour, GMB Scotland secretary, said: "There are clearly questions which are raised about the current procurement practices of the Scottish Government.
"It’s clear that social value is currently being underweighted when it comes to the consideration of bids for ferry contracts.
Ferguson Marine (Image: NQ)
"It's beggars belief that Scotland’s public authorities would actively work to prevent our publicly-owned shipyard from winning contracts and securing jobs and apprentices."
CMAL insists that it ran 'a fair and open procurement process', adding that it did not receive any bids from UK yards for the contract.
But Ferguson Marine told The Herald there was no level playing field because the Turkish yard already had a financial and scheduling head start.
The August 24 Transport Scotland business case said using the same design as the Cemre-built Islay ferries would save significant time and was likely to result in Cemre winning the work.
READ MORE:
Ferguson Marine 'frozen out' of bid for next large CalMac ferry
CMAL takes early ownership of new CalMac ferries amid concerns about Turkish yard
Swinney insists Ferguson Marine has 'secure future' despite CalMac snub
Trade union bosses push for action on promised Ferguson Marine contracts
It warned that failing to secure shipyard slots by the end of 2022 could delay new major vessels until 2027/28 or beyond, with ministers having already demanded urgent options.
But the rush meant a full consultation with island bodies, communities and businesses had 'not been undertaken in the usual manner', although Transport Scotland says island communities subsequently welcomed the proposal for two ferries on the Little Minch routes during November 2022 consultation.
The Port Glasgow yard was, at the time, still struggling to complete Glen Sannox and its sister vessel Glen Rosa - which were originally due to enter service in 2018.
READ MORE:
ScotGov’s four-vessel award plan faces legal and workload concerns
Ferguson's workforce ready to 'restore confidence' in yard, says CEO
Ferguson Marine to boost apprenticeship programme after being awarded new work
Credit for Ferguson Marine yard order lies with union chief, says Labour MSP
Ms Gilmour added: "We are through the looking glass when anonymous, unaccountable civil servants and board members can agree tender documents that effectively bar a publicly-owned shipyard from bidding for publicly-funded contracts.
"It is beyond time for MSPs to hold the secretive and self-harming procurement policies of the Scottish Government and its agencies up to the light."
GMB Scotland says the wider issue is now the future of Ferguson Marine itself.
Ms Gilmour said: "Fergusons successfully built a third of the current CalMac fleet before being burdened with two huge, ill-planned, unsuitable ferries."
GMB's Louise Gilmour (Image: GMB Scotland)
She added: "CMAL and Transport Scotland were absolutely complicit in that process so it adds insult to injury for them to suggest this yard cannot now serve our island communities."
A Transport Scotland spokesman said: “We are committed to maintaining and enhancing the Clyde and Hebrides ferry fleet to improve reliability and provide more capacity on the network. Ordering two additional Islay-class vessels has helped speed up this work and introduce a more standard vessel design.
"They will operate on a wider range of routes, enabling more flexibility and making maintenance more efficient.
READ MORE:
'Ferguson Marine can draw a line under last ten years' says yard union boss
Glen Rosa's move to Inchgreen signals start of Ferguson's transformation
New Ferguson board chair promises to make yard 'modern, efficient and profitable'
Exclusive look inside MV Glen Rosa at Ferguson Marine as engine fires for first time
“The contracts for the two vessels were awarded by CMAL following a single stage competitive procurement process in accordance with the Public Contracts (Scotland) Regulations 2015.
"These new vessels will allow the Little Minch routes to be served by two ferries, instead of one, improving capacity and resilience.
"Island communities welcomed these proposed changes during consultation sessions in November 2022, before the contracts were awarded in January 2023.”
Share